Published on December 12th, 2019 | by Harmonist staff1
Beginningless Ignorance and Endless Love
By Swami B.V. Tripurari
In the Hindu worldview, the world of our mental, sensual, and intellectual experience is something that comes and goes, just like everything within it does. The universe expands and contracts in beginningless and endless cycles. It consists of subjective and objective components and thus gives rise to the questions of “what’s out there?” and “who is asking the question?” The binding force that brings these two components together is karma. And like the world cycles, ourselves, and the objective content of the world, karma is also beginningless. However, unlike everything else, our individual karma can come to an end.
When thinking about this recently, a student of mine asked if I could give an example of anything that had no beginning but could come to an end. I replied that ignorance itself, the root of our karmic predicament—avidya—is beginningless but can come to an end. Do you have experience of such ignorance coming to an end? Think about it. When did your ignorance of any particular subject begin? And have you experienced any such ignorance coming to an end?
We are born into ignorance, an ignorance that was present before we were born. From ignorance comes material desire, and from material desire comes action in relation to the world around us (or our perception of it) and its consequences—karma.
How can this karmic root of ignorance be uprooted? One has to learn to look within. More important than what’s out there is who’s in there asking the question. How much more important, more valuable? Well, there is no value “out there,” no qualitative reality. Quality is a property of the subjective realm, of which we are a unit. As Mark writes, paraphrasing Jesus of Nazareth, What profit is there in gaining the entire objective world at the cost of knowing the subjective observer—the atma—an eternal unit of consciousness?
But our ignorance is deeply rooted and requires more than theoretical knowledge to uproot it. Such knowledge helps, much like knowledge of a psychological dysfunction can be helpful in endeavoring to overcome it. But just as such emotional dysfunctions need to be uprooted emotionally rather than rationally, similarly our karmic conditioning must be uprooted by another form of conditioning, a transrational practice. We require knowledge of the predicament we find ourselves in and a practice to overcome it.
Just as karma is an environmental conditioning derived from investing in the objective world, bhakti is also an environmental conditioning, but it is derived from investing in the realm of consciousness. Spiritual practice—sadhana—is such an investment, one that constitutes the culture of wise love. And in the Gita, bhakti—wise love—is described as the “king of knowledge.” To love is to know. Love involves both knowing and acting combined. On the other hand, karma is action arising out of ignorance. Thus, ending one’s karma amounts to remaining environmentally conditioned but changing the nature of that conditioning such that one is propelled to act devoid of the spirit of exploitation and with love in relation to our source.
And in contrast to our karma arising out of beginningless ignorance that can come to an end, bhakti begins but never ends. How does it begin? It begins with the influence of saintly association—sadhu-sanga—which itself is a form of bhakti. Thus, bhakti comes from bhakti and it is the force by which our beginningless karmic trajectory can come to an end. Bhakti in practice undresses the atma, which in its nakedness is more beautiful in its resemblance to its source than in any role it plays in the dress and drama of karmic samsara, and bhakti in ecstasy re-dresses that atma beautifully and suitably for the date with the Divine.
re: “bhakti begins but never ends. How does it begin? It begins with the influence of saintly association—sadhu-sanga—which itself is a form of bhakti.”
Sadhu-sanga. Srila Prabhupada writes in SB 1.5.25 purport, that one “catches” bhakti just like one catches an infectious disease – by association with the pure devotee that carries that “infection”. And later in that same purport, Srila Prabhupada says, that to become infected with the qualities of the pure devotee means to “imbibe” the taste of devotion of the pure devotee.
With some infectious diseases one becomes infected through intimate association. What can be more intimate than to imbibe the heartfelt flavor or aroma of the heart of one who is saturated with devotional ecstasy. Everyday we sing, “prema bhakti yaha hoite”. “From him Krishna prema emanates”. Just as the light of the sun emanates from the sun and illumines the whole world, ecstatic love of Krishna radiates from the heart of the pure devotee. And our job is to be receptive to that emanation which is freely given.
Srila Prabhupada writes in NOD that if a man is potent and a woman is healthy and pure, there can be conception. Therefore both the teacher and the devotional aspirant must be qualified. Hiranya Kashipu states that “association is like a crystal stone that reflects whatever is put before it.” And Srila Prabhupada writes that if the heart of the student is crystal clear he/she will naturally reflect the devotional qualities of the pure devotee.
So what is the nature of this clarity or purity of heart that enables us to imbibe and reflect that the devotion of the self-realized soul? Krishna describes this progressive process of purification in the Bhagavad-Gita, culminating in the brahma-bhuta platform. In the preceding verses, Krishna tells us that if we can come to the platform beyond “attraction and hate” this sets the ground for attainment of the brahma-bhuta platform in which one begins to take pleasure in the self – “prasanatma”. From this platform of consciousness, Krishna says, one can begin the devotional process in a lovely heartfelt way.
When such a student associates with a pure devotee, they can imbibe the taste of devotion of the such a teacher, and plant that seed within the core of the heart. And by cultivating that seed through their own sadhana they remain fixed up in intimate association of the self-realized soul.
Krishna consciousness is not simply a matter of adherence to a list of do’s and don’ts. It is the most intimate process of being a transcendental understudy in bhakti in the most receptive mood of transcendental empathy – the most intimate relationship of our lives.